Sunday, 28 July 2013

Meg - the first decade gone by

Some two weeks ago I was scoffed at, by my somewhat older female workmates, for sticking to my almost six-years-old, always reliable, Nokia 3110 Classic and not upgrading to an all-the-rage smartphone / iPhone or whatever else a modern corpo-lemming needs to swank. I refuted their half-jocose, half-serious remarks with a question how long their previous devices worked before packing up. Unsurprisingly, one said her previous smartphone had cracked after hitting table surface after being dropped from the height of 20 centimetres, the other’s iPhone had broken down after a few months from purchase, helpless technicians hadn’t known how to fix it and eventually she’d had it replaced under warranty with another shitty iPhone which even doesn’t have a removable battery. Since early 2008 when I purchased my Nokia, it has never let me down. A few times over that time it crashed and I had to turn it off and on, a few times it lost signal and needed a restart, but except for those minor incidents, the handset worked like a clockwork and nothing seems to indicate its end is near. Of course given its age it can conk out any time, but if it happens, I’ll have a justification to buy a better device, probably a low-end smartphone.

The other story is that they also asked me how I can live without access to internet in my mobile phone. Well, the real life is offline and may it stay so. I don’t keep track of the ever-accelerating world and don’t follow my friends on facebook incessantly and don’t miss it. It’s simply healthier not to be in a debilitating state of continuous partial attention… Is it something worth missing out on?

How I’ve used my phone and why I’ve not upgraded to a state-of-the-art device is the essence of my policy towards consumer durables. I generally:
- buy only brand new stuff,
- choose items of good quality, with as many features as I need to have (why paying for gadgets I won’t use?),
- take care of the stuff so that they serve me longer than their built-in obsolescence,
- get rid of them and replace with new when their wear and tear justifies it.

Such should be also the way of handling probably the most expensive consumer durable – a car…

As a matter of principle I wouldn’t buy a used car. Supply of used cars in Poland is limited by low number of sold new cars (many of which serve as company cars which doesn’t bring a good testimony of their condition after a few years of use), so used cars come to Poland from its western neighbours. Given how much I heard and read of crooks trading in used cars, I’d never buy one. Well-maintained used cars are:
- either not for sale, because due to price homogeneity market values them almost at the par with their rickety counterparts, hence owners to well-maintained cars have no motivation to sell them,
- if they are sold, the new owner will be someone from family or friends of an old car owner or a car trader, which brings about negative selection…

With a brand new car you get the producer’s warranty, new technologies and clean history of the vehicle. It does depreciate over the first years rapidly, but why should you care if you plan to keep that car going for 10 – 15 years? You use the car properly, have it serviced at regular intervals, parts which wear out and engine oil are changed when due and the car should serve you for 10 – 15 years. Then comes the moment when each, even the best car, becomes less reliable or simply requires more money sunk to keep it going. Even if repairs are not expensive, you need to take the trouble to find a cheaper spare part, pick it up and have it replaced. So after all there comes the moment to part company with the old car without regrets and buy a brand new car that should serve you years. Provided in the era of built-on obsolescence the newly produced car are that durable... Time will tell…

The reason why I write it all is that today is the 10th anniversary of the day when my car was purchased. As a young driver I’ve been in the luck of having my first car neither purely brand-new (not recommendable for beginners behind the wheel), nor purely used. My parents signed it over to me two years ago when my father decided he wanted a new car. Probably hadn’t it been for my need (a proper word, maybe I should write ‘whim’) to have a car, he would’ve driven it for some time more, but given the circumstances, the choice was obvious…

After 10 years the car still looks well and holds up well. Engine and transmission are in superb condition, bodywork and some of auxiliary elements signify their wear and tear (although there is no trace of rust!). To the right – snapped on 18 June 2013 after a wash and some polishing ;) Maybe not like driven out of showroom, but as for a decade-old vehicle, looks splendidly.

The car:
- has never had a collision on the road, although has scratches and one repaired dent after too close meeting with objects other than other vehicles,
- has never broken down on the road to the extent it had to be towed away to a garage on a trailer and never has it failed to start,
- has always been serviced by Renault dealership’s garage (a bit more expensive, but as long as you prove you know the onions and keep tabs on mechanics, they won’t rip you off) and most of the time parked in a garage,
- when I was behind the wheel endured temperatures (thermometer readings) from –24C (cold start, not just driving out of garage into such temperature) to +36C and tomorrow the latter record stands a chance of being tomorrow, when heat wave that has come over Poland is about to reach its zenith),
- over 10 years had 6 breakdowns of auxiliary elements (in a French car inevitable), out of which 3 over the 3rd year of usage and 2 over the last year (total cost of unplanned repairs over the last year: slightly less than 500 PLN) and 2 minor breakdowns of engine / transmission – related elements (cost of repair below 1,000 PLN each time),
- at the moment has a mileage of 59,693 kilometres.

The odometer reading is the effect of simply using the car only when necessary. As I counted, the car had 13 longer trips (> 100 kilometres to a destination) which contributed to some 10,000 kilometres of mileage, the rest driven near Warsaw. My general principles are:
- if the distance to cover is too short to let the engine heat up, there’s no point in starting it – engine and other elements wear out most before working temperatures is reached (for the same reason I don’t understand why people cherish low-mileage car from someone who used it only on short distances – what’s the percentage of mileage driven with warm engine?),
- in Warsaw, unless justified, the car should be left by the nearest underground station and then public transport should be taken,
- when weather permits and I don’t go to work, I use a bicycle…

The plan now is to use the car as long as it is reliable. Given its age, frequent breakdowns may begin to plague before long, but I hope to enjoy at least two years of problem-free usage. And then – option one is another car for years, but preferable is the second option – a company car. Even if I had to pay for petrol from my own pocket, it would spare me depreciation, servicing, repairs, insurance and other car-related expenses, which at the end of the day are… money down the drain.

Sunday, 21 July 2013

The Southern Bypass – probably not the last update

The promise kept. The weather this morning was anything, but not conducive to cycling. Clear blue skies, warm, but not hot (slightly below +20C), northerly breeze taking the gloss off heat. Perfect conditions to get on the bike and check the progress on local section of the Southern Bypass of Warsaw, according to original plans, scheduled to be opened in April 2012.

I cycle safely up the cycle path along ul. Puławska, then use the pavements rather than road. When behind the wheel I’m so fed up with irresponsible cyclists (the worst incidences of thoughtlessness among drivers and cyclist can be observed on narrowed section of ul. Puławska where junction with the Bypass is being built) that I never share the street with cars on busy roads. It’s safer for everyone – I have to mind the pedestrians or cycle slowly on bumpy roadside, but don’t need to worry that a carefree speeding meathead runs me down.

I turn left to ul. Ludwinowska and a few minutes later I reach the intersection with ul. Poloneza. The dirt track running to the newly built splendid viaduct over the bypass has been hardened some time ago. Once I even dared to drive there in an attempt to pass by Friday afternoon traffic jam on ul. Puławska. I drove mere 15 kpmh and was overtaken by three hell-bent drivers, probably all in company cars. Hasty bastards whipped up huge billows of dust which until now lingers on my car’s bodywork…

Reluctant to pedal hard, I scramble up the viaduct and look towards ul. Puławska. A layman’s eye tells me finishing works are left to be done on this section and long-awaited opening may come to a pass. I finally see the light at the end of this tunnel. Opening in 4Q2013 is doable, provided the recent pace of work is kept up…

Then I ride west to cycle up the other viaduct that takes ul. Hołubcowa over the expressway. To the right – this time looking west, towards junction Lotnisko. Compared to what I saw here in early March, the road builders have caught up impressively. The recent progress is commendable, but won’t outshine slackness of the contractor over the first 3 years of construction.

I roam around the vicinity of the junction, walk down the technical stairway and snap this. These are the two main roads of the bypass, each designed to be divided into three lanes, running beneath Radom line tracks. Unlike many other cyclists, I didn’t take a ride through the road. The works were not running at full steam, yet some vehicles were moving there and some workers were busy tidying up the expressway. Unlike most Poles I have much respect for health and safety and avoid entering areas I should keep away from. It’s not about being reproved by a security guard, but about my own safety. A driver of huge truck should focus on his work rather than on watching out for reckless trip-makers…

Then I head home down ul. Hołubcowa. Using the word ‘ulica’ to describe the bumpy dirt track is at best a misnomer. The track, passable for SUVs and cyclists, allows me to get to ul. Baletowa and what I spot behind the level crossing…? A police car. The policemen were lurking behind shrubs to catch drivers ignoring the ‘STOP’ signage before the crossing. I must admit whenever visibility permits I also do not bring the car to a halt. Who knows how high the fine for such misdemeanour is?

To the right – water retention ponds by ul. Kórnicka. Lifts the spirit whenever I can see something that looks decently. Hope the new ponds will do their job properly and protect nearby area from flooding after copious rainfalls…

Sunday, 14 July 2013

Looking for a summertime hangout

While being a visitor to far-flung places, I usually am enchanted by proximity of summertime leisure spots for locals. Easy to discern such places when pop by an specific area for a while, but you pass them by several times, such venues do not impress you… Why?

When summer is at its height, the weather is fine and you are staying in town, only sinners and layabouts pickle at home. Nearby places of leisure should beckon and the temptation must not be resisted. For those living in the southern suburbs of Warsaw, I prepared a short guide to local tourist attractions – places “within a stone’s throw” being a good location to spend summer afternoons.

Las Kabacki – huge forest within southern borders of Warsaw. From where I live you can get to several entries to it in several ways: by car (not recommended), by bus (also not my favourite), on foot (kind of far away, especially if you happen you walk in +30 heat), or by bike (most recommended).
Key advantages: proximity, trees give shelter from the heat.
Key disadvantages: range of activities is confined to: walking, running, cycling; the very latter is prohibited on many paths, crowds of people on Saturdays and Sundays…

Powsin – when saying this you may mean either botanic garden or leisure park. The latter is more popular among inhabitants of southern Warsaw districts and can be easily reached by 519 bus (provided the routes have not been changed), by wide and popular cycling path running from Wilanów, by car and on foot. The most preferable way of getting there is of course by bike – not only healthy and pleasurable, but also inexpensive and not time consuming and spares you the problem of “where to park my car”.
Key advantages: good place for a date ;-), gives shelter from heat, lots of bars and possibility to do sports, feels like being on holidays.
Key disadvantages: from my where I live, kind of far away, but for migrants living in their mortgaged apartments in Wilanów – ideal…

Konstancin sanatoria park – the town where my grandparents live has a specific micro-climate, making even over +30C heat more bearable. The phenomenon of slightly cooler spot is noticeable all over the year. During winter thaws snows linger there much longer than in Warsaw or Piaseczno. The park and tężnia have been refurbrished quite recently and have become popular with locals and Varsovians. The destination can be reached in same ways as previous ones (take 710 bus from Piaseczno or from Metro Wilanowska terminus).
Key advantages: good place for a date ;-), fresh, humid air, gives shelter from the heat, many cafes and restaurants around.
Key disadvantages: crowded to the limits at times, cycling in the park is not impossible, but being considerate to comfort and safety or pedestrians requires you to take off your bike, kind of expensive if you want to eat out a lot.

Pond in Mysiadło – well, the nearest spot to my home, just 1 kilometre (to the right, shot on 1 May 2012). There was a time when local authorities wanted to invest in a place and turn it around a magnificent outdoor leisure centre. The pond was meant to be cleaned up, including the floor, where you could find rubbish dumped there back when PGR Mysiadło was in operation, sand was meant to be dumped to the shore, some more benches put up… Plans were ambitious and eventually have been given up. The place is now only a hangout for local pissheads, teenagers and anglers. Actually almost everyone who sits by the pond has the same goal in mind – boozing. Not recommended. And given virtually everyone sees in the pond area a booze-up venue, plans to revitalise the place will be hard to pursue.

Górki Szymona – allegedly the pride and joy of Piaseczno. Maybe I am biased, but if the town in which I spent first seventeen years of my life has anything to boast about, I’m a Dutchman. I ventured there last Sunday to check out how the place where I would go with my parents some twenty years ago looks and, unsurprisingly, little has changed.

To the right – the standpipe is where it was in 1994, I recall well my father developed a habit of parking his Fiat Uno next to it. Only the trees are higher, the road running towards the place has not even been tarmacked… In the background – a chap (was not a pleasure to cycle past him, the odour could not be captured by the camera) pushing a rubbish cart – fits the place perfectly.

To the right – for a short moment I forget I am mere three miles from home and imagine I’m holidaying. There’s a lake, there’s a pier, an angler on the other side. Behind me someone has pitched a tent and its dwellers are eating breakfast.

To the right – the sand-covered hill, why and wherefore this place is named the way it is named. In my childhood it was the place most ‘tourists’ would lay their blankets and towels. Nearby was a sandy shore and swimming baths.

To the right – I tried to cycle around the pond and ride through a wide footpath. It is the only place in the whole area that seems to have a spirit. Finally I did not dare to cover the whole path by bike and turned back. I have to confess I did not feel safe there in broad daylight.

This is the essence of Piaseczno – I feel safer in Warsaw late in the evening than in Piaseczno on a Sunday afternoon. On my way to Górki Szymona I was accosted by four tanked-up hools trying to deprive me of my bike. Fortunately the incident ended just with an exchange of “pleasantries”. Local authorities also want to revitalise the area and attract not only locals by letting a private investor build a guesthouse. I doubt those ideas ever prove successful.

Key advantages: proximity (less than half an hour by bike for me to get there), there’s water out there
Key advantages: not sure if swimming there is safe, whether the water is clean, no other attractions around, no snack bar, etc., shady spot…

So if this is not the right direction, next weekend, weather permitting, I plan to check and document the progress of works on the Southern Bypass of Warsaw, from junction Puławska to so-called Grande Canale, the least advanced section of the road.

Sunday, 7 July 2013

Pension system overhaul - follow-up

The topic of pension system reform, my hobby horse, will be keeping us company in the coming weeks. The final decision on the future shape of the pension system in Poland is bound to be taken and announced around the end of summer holidays. Until then several consultations will be run in order to work out compromise on the variant which will be chosen and pursued. Meetings have kicked off and judging by what politicians and government-related economists declare, we are drifting towards the second option, i.e. freedom to choose whether to still transfer part of pension contribution which now goes to private-run pension funds there or to move it to state-run social security fund.

A week ago I mentioned the calculations presented in the government report, whose accuracy has been called into question by independent (?) economists. I took the trouble to download calculations presented by independent economists (in a spreadsheet) and set about analysing them. I can only agree with independent economists that money-weighted rate of return (actually in essence internal rate of return) is a proper and more accurate tool for assessing investment performance that geometric mean. I spent some half an hour poring over the complicated spreadsheet to work out why specific formulas are in specific cells and find causations between them. Then I began to verify assumptions on which calculation had been made. I found a factual error in decreasing fees charged by pension fund managers (not impacting substantially the upshots), but then gave up on further exploration as it was before eleven, it was dark and my mind simply began to drift away. Had I spent one more evening doing all the stuff, I would have probably been able to tell whether the independent economists’ calculations were correct. Third evening for verification of government’s calculations and I would have been home. But in the first week of July when weather is perfect, there are much more interesting things to do than taking apart the report, if it is not going to change anything…

The silver-mouthed politician of the week award goes to Leszek Miller, chief(tain) of SLD. On Tuesday in the public radio he put forward calling parliamentary investigating committee to track and bring to the light irregularities in setting up and running pension funds. Having read the transcript of the interview I can say that:
1) There is no need to call any committee to find out pension fund managing companies charged over 17 billion PLN in fees from contributions paid by future pensioners. They did it within the letter of law (because politicians allowed them to do so), extensive reports on profitability and solvency of pension fund industry are available on Polish Financial Services Authority’s website and everyone (computer-literate) can easily find the numbers,
2) Personal tie-ups of reform-authors with beneficiaries of the reform are disclosed to the public. You may speak here about arrogance, lack of integrity, but not of withheld tie-ups.
3) If indeed it is true that powerful financial corporations lobbied for the reform to secure for themselves risk-free business, they surely did not spare efforts to efface all the traces of what could be found illegal and the committee would not be able to track it.
4) If Leszek Miller suggests pension fund managers were “pumping up” prices of some shares and there were investors in the know of it and benefited from this and he has evidence of such incidents, may he go to relevant supervision authorities. What Mr Miller speaks of is an example of insider trading, which is a (n easy to detect, difficult to prove) crime. Bodies which deal with such form if criminality in Poland are Financial Services Authority (KNF) and Prosecutor’s Office.

On Friday Mr Miller announced his grouping would pass a resolution condemning bygone prime minister Jerzy Buzek and bygone finance minister Leszek Balcerowicz for the pension reform. I know there are thousands or even millions of people in this country deeply convinced pension system reform, in particular creating pension funds, was the biggest scam made in Poland after 1989. Mr Miller also knows it (just as he knows there are millions of Poles hankering after Gierek’s decade) and in his cynical game wants to score a point by speaking out what those people have in minds. I shall refrain from explicit comments, this is pure politics, not policy, something that adds no value to moving Poland forward.

On Tuesday the runner-up, Jarosław Gowin reasserted he thinks “in pension funds there are Poles’ private monies” and insisted in case pension funds are scrapped, it would be best to give that money back to Poles (incidentally Mr Gowin failed to pin down what he actually meant). Last week I outlined a scenario of freeing the assets accumulated in pension funds, this week I will just paste a fictitious news item, thought out by me and posted on my wall on facebook – dedicated to philosopher Gowin.


It does not take a lawyer, nor the Supreme Court ruling, to come to the conclusion public pension fund assets are not private savings, it is a matter of logic, you just need to use your brains.

The conclusions I reached after the last week are depressing. An average Pole knows little of economics. Loads of useless stuff are taught at schools and except for short course of “entrepreneurship” run in high schools, youngsters in Poland are not educated in the workings of economy. I estimate 80% of Poles do not understand what the whose fuss about OFE is about and hence are pliable - one day can believe the government, the other they will believe Mr Balcerowicz is right. Due to lack of education they have to take what they are told on trust. Imagine how much room for misrepresentations, manipulations, populism and propaganda it leaves.

Politicians and journalists also lack proper knowledge and understanding of the topic. Let’s take the example of a sentence “oszczędzać na emeryturę w ZUS-ie”, in English ‘to save for pension in [state-run] Social Security Fund’, literally in “Social Insurance Company”. Stare-run pillar of the pension system is an insurance scheme. When you work you pay contributions and in fact take out insurance from not having subsistence when you retire. It is an example of endowment insurance policy with no payout before maturity. Get it? If not imagine you take out non-compulsory car insurance. If your car is not damaged, nor stolen, has the insurance stolen your premium. In state-run pension system you buy protection, not benefit. Had it been the other way round, the system would have collapsed, or contributions would have been raised.

The other story is poor informational quality lack of clarity in public speaking. This drawback of Polish public discourse is partly the effect of poor understanding of complicated issues. The other, very rare ability most public figures lack, is the aptitude to explain complex issue in simple words, intelligible for an ordinary recipient. Even if somebody has knowledge, difficulties in putting it across make it useless for the society!

Now let’s move a level higher. Imagine the recipient is an educated graduate of economics, who not just holds a diploma, but is familiar with the stuff and avidly interested in it. If such person needs some six hours (maybe it is little) to determine whether rates of return in the report were correctly calculated, does the whole debate not move to another universe, completely out of reach for ordinary people? Should an average citizen know whether geometric mean, or money-weighted rate of return is apposite for comparing investment results? Does this give politicians and economists right to deprive benighted people of the right to decide how to secure their retirement? Thus I moved to the realm of questions doomed to be unanswered which reminds me today’s writing has come to an end.

Sunday, 30 June 2013

Nie będę płakać po OFE - pension system overhaul

With some considerable delay, the Polish government unveiled this week the long-awaited report containing a comprehensive analysis of the Polish pension system and recommendations for coming changes into its workings. Regular readers of this blog probably know the topic and my opinion on it inside out, yet if somebody has to catch up, follow these posts. The report, in Polish, can be found here. I have not found any English-language summary of it, yet for the sake of brevity, I will not summarise it, nor repeat anything I have written before as there have been no fundamental changes that need to be underlined.

Defenders of private-run pension funds being a part of public social security system have, predictably, torn a strip off its authors, accusing government-linked experts of manipulations, lies and use of propaganda, funnily enough without pointing at any specific example. The critics also say calculations presented in the report are distorted. Due to shortage of time and data, I cannot check accuracy of calculations presented in the report, yet if the only accusation is that the government presented investment results of pension funds net-of-fees, rather than gross-of-fees, then jaw drops open helplessly. For my part, I have found the report surprisingly substantive and unbiased and see in it one of few commendable recent attainments of PO-led government.

Albeit, let’s face the truth, this overhaul is carried out not because minister Rostowski cares so much about future benefits of the Polish pensioners, but the key incentive for pursuing it is the tightness of public finances.

The report analyses inter alia the impact of private-run pension funds on capital markets. As an analyst I have seen a few examples of stock-listed companies in which pension funds were major investors and those companies, actively managed by key shareholders, have been well-run. For many companies capital provided by pension funds was indispensable for development and proved a successful investment. Pension funds also contributed to development of Warsaw Stock Exchange and helped it grow to be the biggest such institution in CEE. But there is also the other side of the coin. The processes which have had favourable impact on Polish capital market will one day, due to changes in demographic trends, reverse. Today pension funds are net buyer of securities, but in a few decades outflows from pension funds will surpass inflows, as fewer people will work and pay contributions and more will be paid benefits. Then pension funds will be putting a downward pressure on stock prices and will have to dispose of some of its assets… Due to active ownership of shares in stock-listed companies, the recklessly made decision to nationalise the pool of assets in pension funds invested in stocks as it would have detrimental impact on Polish stock market and economy.

Pension fund defenders convince pension funds have contributed to higher GDP growth rate, while the government claims the effect on economic growth has been negative. The former back their assertion by arguments I mentioned in the paragraph above, the latter point out transfers of part of pension contributions transferred to private-run pension funds, which had to be replenished by subsidies from state budget, increased government’s borrowing needs, debt-to-GDP ratio and thus debt service costs. However, the same debt was later purchased by pension funds, hence increased demand for borrowing from the government was balanced by increased demand from pension funds – those two have cancelled each other out, leaving yields on government bonds roughly unchanged, with some intermediaries (private companies managing pension funds) charging a considerable percentage of that “hollow circulation of funds” as fee for facilitating the process. Their revenues, from standpoint of future pensioners generated a loss.

The report highlights the problem of “double-tax generation”. One of the goals of the pension reform in Poland was a shift from pay-as-you-go to capital system. Under such move, one working generation had to pay contributions for benefits of current retirees and, at the same time, “save” for their own pensions. Is such burden not to heavy to carry? Authors of the reformed wanted to fill the gap by proceeds from privatisation, as the generation of current retirees, working in socialist Poland, had built many of the big state-controlled companies. Privatisation itself should be a goal, but not at any price and not to, let’s face it, meet current government expenses. The whole concept of privatisation as source of funding for the reform, resembles me a granny who sells her unnecessary jewellery to make ends meet. Whether it is wise – I am not the one to judge it…

The issue hardly anyone broaches is conditionality of state’s liabilities towards pensioners. In the Social Security Fund you have book records, while in pension funds you have government securities. Both are the government’s promise to pay, either directly a pension, either to repay bondholders. However, due to form of insurance, book records in Social Security Fund are conditional – these liabilities turn partly unconditional, when a Fund member retires; in pension funds, where assets can be inherited, the liability is conditional as long as a member does not retire. Minister Rostowski declared the part of assets transferred from pension funds to Social Security Fund will also be inheritable, hence in such way state budget would not be better off.

And the last problem, with which I have not come up – frankly speaking I hatched the idea on one of Internet forums – is the functioning of pension funds in the light of MIFID. Under investor protection regulations, if I was to pay my money into investment fund with exactly the same investment policy as a strictly regulated pension fund, I would be obliged to fill in a survey to check suitability of such investment for me, and in case of unsuitability, I would be warned against it and would have to sign a statement despite the warning I want to invest in a risky product. In the case of pension funds, nobody bothers to follow such procedure, which disproves the untrue claim that “in pension funds there are people’s money”.

The government presented for further discussion 3 variants:

1. The pool of assets in pension funds comprising of government securities is transferred to Social Security Fund and booked on accounts allocated to future pensioners. Other assets in pension funds remain intact, 2.92% out of 19.52% pension contribution goes to private-run pension funds which are not allowed to invest in government-issued securities, the rest goes to Social Security Fund. Furthermore, internal benchmark mechanism (pathological) is scrapped, but indebtedness ceiling level (currently 50%, 55%, 60% of debt-to-GDP) are accordingly decreased to prevent rise in public debt.

2. Citizens are free to choose, whether to participate in private-run pension funds, or to rely only on state-run Social Security System. The proposal, as I far as I could notice, does not pin down the split of contribution between state- and private-run parts of the system. This option is more controversial, as system participants would have to submit declarations they want to stay in a specific pension fund; not submitting a declaration would mean silent assent for transfer of assets to Social Security Fund, plus such decision would be irrevocable, while the decision to stay in a pension fund could be revoked any time in the future). Moreover, there is a problem what to do with shares of companies transferred to Social Security – this would be hard nut to crack, yet feasible, the report contains some recommendations with feasibility and drawback analyses. The idea to “write off” government bonds transferred to Social Security Fund would have to be thoroughly analysed by lawyers, as this smacks of sovereign default!

3. Extended freedom to choose – if someone chooses to stay with a pension funds, pension contribution to private-run funds would be 2 percentage points (in relation to pre-tax salary) higher. If you read between the lines, the message is “if you think private-run pension funds are so good, why not pay them more?)

The government also resolved that state-run Social Security System will be responsible for all benefit payments and assets from pension funds will be gradually transferred to Social Security Fund over last 10 years before retirement, to minimise risk of lower pension due to downturn on financial markets.

As commentators say, variant 3 is least likely to go through, while oppositional parties lean towards variant 2. I also hold the view that, despite some of its drawbacks, would be the lesser of all evils and, if amended properly (I put forward a citizen has to submit a declaration if they want to have assets allocated to them transferred to Social Security Fund and shifts between state-run and private-run funds could be done many times and in both way, of course in minimum intervals of let’s say 6 months), should be implemented.

What I did not like about the report is that private-run pension funds and their managers who have ripped over 17 billion PLN off future pensioners are presented as scapegoats. They are only a beneficiaries of legal framework created by politicians and if somebody is to blame, these are politicians, who passed such law, thanks to social support achieved thanks to several misrepresentations. Imagine you are a wife and your husband asks in his buddies to your house and lets them eat the whole content of your fridge, piss in your garden and demolish your furniture – your husband is to blame, not the buddies who were allowed to do damages.

One of my colleagues from work told me pension funds from the beginning were meant to be the scapegoat (not only the best, for reasons below, business on earth). In fact, to tackle demographic problems you only had to shift from benefit-defined to contribution-defined system, raise retirement age, scrap some privileges and create legal framework for voluntary private-run system of pension saving or insurance. At the end of the day, how high pension benefits will be depends only on standing of the economy, as investment results of pension fund in the long run depend on them. This means obligatory pension funds create little value added, and, provided calculations in the report are accurate, costs they generate are higher than value added they generate.

Now comes the time for consultancies. The debate will be fierce, as the prime minister said, big money is at stake – but for both sides of the argument. Minister Rostowski will play for more balanced budget, pension funds and its defenders will play for state-guaranteed source of profits on risk- and responsibility-free business. And I believe interests of the future pensioners are somewhere near the bottom of the list of priorities defenders are opponents of pension funds have.

I only fear the pension funds will draw another divide line in the Polish society. We have Poles who believe Martial Law in 1981 prevented a disaster and Poles who believes general Jaruzelski (turning 90 next Saturday) declared it despite there was no threat of Soviet intervention only to nip in the bud growing social movement. We have Poles who believe Smolensk crash was a tragic accident being aftermath of human errors and Poles who believe it was an assassination. From now we will have Poles praising government for dismantling the biggest scam in over 20 years of Third Republic of Poland and Poles believing the government wants to take over their money.

For the very end, I was deeply astonished by press conference on Friday by Mr. Balcerowicz, one of leading defenders of pension funds. When I looked at his wrathful face when he avidly spoke of “lies, misrepresentations and propaganda” I feared he would kick the bucket. He did not, but I am curious to find out why he failed to mention a single, specific lie and disprove it. Is it so difficult to say “the statement you can find on page X, paragraph X of the report, i.e. “quote” is untrue, because this and that”? Why has he not done it?

The release of the report coincides also with congress of the Civic Platform, held this weekend. It made me realise if I were to choose, I would opt for Donald Tusk’s platform, not Jarosław Gowin’s one. I opt for moderate economic and social liberalism, not conservatism. But above all, I opt for sound mind and common sense!

Sunday, 23 June 2013

Too much filth will kill you...

Back from holidays again – experienced a total logout from work and tomorrow the first thing I’ll need will be a password reset to access my computer. Even the weather diffidently signals time to return to corpo-world has come – the recent heat wave gave way to a downpour and temperatures plunged by 10C, giving a blissful relief from the heat. And may it stay so…

Got some time to catch up with film watching and finally watched Drogówka, the fourth film by Wojtek Smarzowski which went on the silver screens in February this year.

Mr Smarzowski’s film-directing attainment is definitely incomparable to any other contemporary film-maker in Poland. To put it briefly, in Smarzowski’s world there’s no choice between good and evil, the best option is only the lesser of tow evils… In his (in)famous four films he deftly depicts the darkest side of life, pouring the filth into the audience, making you want to take a shower and wash away all the dirt that has stuck to you while watching.

For many people I know even his first film, Wesele, released in 2004 and favourably received by critics, was intolerable. The film is actually a very ‘light’ depiction of the dark side of Polish mentality, showed in the background of a provincial wedding. The story of pregnant bride coerced to marry a groom bought-off by his would-be father-in-law sheds light on the worst traits of provincial duplicity: caring more about “what people say” (keeping up appearances) and money than about relatives’ happiness. Striking shady business is more important than grandpa’s sudden death, stolen Audi TT is more important than just-married wife and a child she will give birth to. Well-done and well-balanced art…

Dom Zły (especially with English subtitles, Jamie, are you still with us?) takes you back to the days of Martial Law and, in retrospections, to late 1970s. The picture is dirty, at times vulgar and explicit, yet taking into account the purport of the film, suitable. Form should fit the content and in this case the balance is still struck.

I’m ashamed to admit I haven’t found time, even in the last days (when still I was kind of busy doing some overdue refurbishment works around the house), to watch Róża. My mother, who watched it (but refused to watch it with me), told me cruelty and filth was dosed out moderately. The film, set in post-war reality of “regained lands” shows the dark side of events that actually took place and the depiction simply lacks censorship that would erase the ugliest parts. Yet, as critics say, given the historical background, use of abhorrent content is justifiable.

Compared to the newest Smarzowski’s film, the three previous could be classified as late-afternoon cartoons for polite children. In Drogówka, subsidised by State Film Art Institute and favourably reviewed by critics, the batty director has gone over the top and I will stand up for this view despite by general insensitivity to filth. The film was meant to over-expose all the pathologies plaguing the Polish police, in particular its road traffic forces. In fact only some of the pathologies showed in the film are the daily bread – these are mainly use of foul language or offensive jokes. Other alleged afflictions depicted in the film are simply marginal problems – gone are the days of wide-spread corruption, hardly ever can you find policemen gaining fortunes on bribery, regularly visiting brothels and raping accidentally met women. When the film was released I found the police representative’s statement, claiming the film discredits police, exaggerated and unfounded. Upon watching this and sticking it out (which I consider a success, as the plot is anything but gripping) I have to take back my words. As three previous film showed actual dark side of life, were waspish and cruel, yet fair, this one is a one massive distortion. The amount of obscene content is also fairly overdosed. The film could have done without explicit scenes of anal sex in the escort agency and one of the last scenes – oral sex on the back seat of a car, tragically ended by rear-ending could have also been edited out and without those two shots the film would have soaked with filth anyway. I have nothing against showing moral downfall, as I believe when it exists in fact, as such eye-popping naturalism showed to the public may help eradicate evil. In Drogówka intensity of filth might be unbearable even for the toughest audience.

I only wonder whether Mr Smarzowski takes pleasure in shooting such films. With each next film his exploration of dirt gets deeper, naturalism grows into over-naturalism and I don’t feel like watching his next attempt, no matter how many stars it receives in review in “Co jest grane”…

Sunday, 2 June 2013

Pamiątkowe rupiecie - book review

Two paragraphs below are an adapted and abridged translation of the book’s blurb.

Wisława Szymborska was anything but delighted to have learnt Anna Bikont and Joanna Szczęsna were writing her biography. As she found personal confessions inappropriate, she avoided like a plague telling stories of her private life. Despite this, the authors managed to persuade the poet to meet, which resulted in unveiling several astounding stories and facts from the past of the Noble prize winner. During a series of meetings Szymborska amazingly and humorously commented on various stages of her life and work. The story is supplemented with memories of the poet’s friends and pieces of poetry interspersed throughout. 

The book is a first full-scale biography of the Noble prize winner, substantially complemented in comparison to the first edition, issued after the Noble prize was awarded. The authors added chapters covering eventful last fifteen years of the poet’s life. They investigated hitherto unknown details from her life and enhanced the content with first-published photographs. The portrait of Szymbowska grew in dignity and depth, yet has not lost any of its lightness. The poet’s death marked the end of some era in the history of Polish literature. While reading this fascinating biography, full of anecdotes and poems, descriptions of journeys and testimonies of friendships, we can taste the climate of Szymborska’s era…
 
Encouraging, isn’t it? Even if the translation (mine) is imperfect…

Had a chance to read this book during early May weekend, yet have hung back on review, on account of, as usually, being short of time.

As indicated by the blurb, the insight into the poet’s private life was extremely hard-gained and it makes the book even more valuable and attention-gripping. Whatever you could say about Wisława Szymbowska, she was anyone, but a celebrity. The last thing she needed was publicity and as much as she could she avoided public appearances, which usually made her feel uncomfortable. Compared to most contemporary public figures who feel at ease being in the limelight, she was a misfit. I somehow feel sympathy with her in this respect…

The poet’s natural modesty, as emphasised repeatedly in the book, was her outstanding feature. And when encountering the poet, when observing her behaviour, you could feel this was not a feigned modesty, not a mask worn to gain accolades. Her manners exuded naturalness, you could almost sense her attitude to life was genuine, no room for acting…

Just to mention a few moments from the poet’s life that seem to deserve most attention in the context of how Szymborska will go down in history and controversies arousing around her. She survived WW2, witnessed inhuman cruelty and then the land she was born became a part of the Soviet bloc. The war brutality and duplicity of Church observed in the childhood put her faith in God to a test. Out of religious teenage girl, she evolved into doubting and seeking woman. She could not claim to be an atheist, yet rather an agnostic. Such openly declared beliefs turned against her in 1996. When she was awarded the Noble prize, right-wing lunatics instantaneously raised outcry over her steering clear of Catholicism and some other facts from her life she would never conceal.

These inconvenient facts Szymborska would never hide was her was post-war fascination with communism. Just like many people she wholeheartedly believed the new system would bring equality and common happiness. She actually discerned inhumanity of communism, but in the period of being totally besotted, she, and many of her peers, took in all the justifications for the system’s cruelty. She was infamous for writing an elegy after Stalin’s death (you can find it in the book), or writing commendation of North-Korean soldiers fighting capitalist invaders. She lost her faith in communism after the system thawed out in the second half of 1950s and in the 1960s she threw away her party membership card. She would never withhold her immature fascination with communism and claimed this was genuine, not opportunistic. She brought herself several times to account for this, yet the time could not be turned back. This stage in her life and poetry should not be forgotten, yet definitely should be forgiven.

Pieces of Szymboska’s poems have been deftly interspersed throughout stories from her life. I must admit the match is in most cases perfect – facts from life are marvellously illustrated with poems, often created on the spur of the moment. Or maybe the stories have been selected and put into apposite order to fit messages hidden in the outstanding poetry?

For the ones who have not been very familiar with Szymborska’s work, the book offers an opportunity to delve into remarkable poetry. As soon as you read several short poem, you realise the Noble prize was undeniably well-deserved. Some of the poems are translated into foreign languages, including English. The translation I read (I can’t quote it now, the book was borrowed and I forgot to scan the relevant page) was noteworthy and deftly rendered the poem’s message, while retaining natural flow and rhythm.

Szymborska’s artwork exudes with unique combination of simplicity and complexity. Striking a balance between the two in any genre is a challenging task and attaining it with a huge dose of sensitivity seldom happens. This only proves the poet’s uncommon aptitude that should outlast next generation of Poles.

Expect the next posting in the second half of June – holidaying until 16 June again ;-)

Sunday, 26 May 2013

A trip to Dolnośląskie

All the good things have to come to an end… Taking a long-awaited and well-deserved holiday break helped me recharge batteries and forget about most of everyday worries. All the plans, social and sight-seeing-related have been followed out, so with no regrets tomorrow I’m bound to submerge into corpo-world. However, before I brace myself for a head-on collision with the recently upsetting murky corporate reality, let’s share some uncanny pictures and thoughts from the days off…

The Sky Tower in Wroclove, to the right shot from the street level, on its south-west edge. The tallest building in Wrocław was under construction in late summer 2011 when I last visited the city. Construction works were finished in 2012. The edifice built by Mr Leszek Czarnecki, one of the richest Poles, comprises of shopping mall, offices and apartments and there have been ample controversies surrounding the building, its design and whether its fits the rest of Wrocław in terms of architecture.

You may like its design or not, but you can’t fail to discern it. It’s visible from all main roads running to Wrocław from the distance of some 50 kilometres and right away it should strike you that the structure stands out in terms of height – the second tallest building in Wrocław is two times smaller… Its shape – looks like a tube sliced aslant – is a distinguishing mark. Whatever the owner and architects wanted to achieve has been achieved – no matter whether the building’s design falls in with your taste, pretty nobody passes it by indifferently.

To the right – north-eastern entrance to the shopping mall. Lipstick on a big, as I called this peculiar composition – the sculpture “Profile of time” by Salvador Dali was put up outside the building in April 2012 and has sat there since then. To make it clear – I have nothing against placing the piece of craftwork there and find it one of more attention-deserving examples of contemporary art (bringing to mind the timeless picture by Salvador Dali), but who the hell has come up with the ridiculous idea to mar the sculpture with the advertising screen put up just next to it? Does this stand for due respect for art? Or is the craftwork meant to serve the consumerism?

Sky Tower overlooks Wrocław and the further from it you move, the more likely you are to discern the characteristic tube in the distance. To the right, a photo taken from the southern fringes of Wrocław, where Al. Wyścigowa (former national road no. 8) and Al. Karkonoska  (National road no. 5) converge and then run towards A4 motorway. Before motorway bypass of Wrocław was opened this was a place where all the southbound transit traffic would meet…

Between the afore- mentioned streets one can find a cemetery of Soviet Soldiers. Cannons and tanks have been giving a warm welcome to all visitors coming to Wrocław since late 1940s when the necropolis was laid. This is one of many similar places in Poland (including the cemetery in Warsaw by ul. Żwirki i Wigury) commemorating the Soviet soldiers who “sacrificed their lives to liberate Poland”. The inscription to the right literally says: “HERE REST THE SOVIET ARMY SOLDIERS, PARTICIPANTS OF WROCLAW BATTLES WHO HAVE LAID DOWN THEIR LIVES FOR LIBERTY AND INDEPENDENCE OF NATIONS OF POLAND AND THE SOVIET UNION”. Unless you are a hard-line commie, you should at least bridle at this pack of lies. What liberty? What independence? Many lunatics would probably be in cloud nine, if only they could obliterate such places of commemoration and go unpunished. I in turn hold the view such places should be taken care of and stay unharmed to bear testimony for next generations, also to bear testimony of omnipresent lies on which the totalitarian system was founded. Besides, those soldiers who rest there, were also victims of communism, cogs in a machine who were meant to die in order to let the Soviet empire expand westwards… They, as all humans, deserve a place of peaceful rest…

Coming to down-to-earth issues:

The weather was clement until Wednesday afternoon when temperature unexpectedly plunged and fell to mere +5C on Thursday morning. Given that spring came later than usual this year, some northern slopes in Karkonosze were still covered with snow (to the right, view from Kowary).

And two shots from Jelenia Góra – to the right, a pebble from Jelenia Góra, encased in cobblestone in the market square. Long story why it’s been here, every why has a wherefore. If any of the readers bothers to tell the anecdote, I’d be more than grateful…

To the right, again Jelenia Góra – every city must have its focal point, but few have it marked so distinctly. Interestingly, this is an element of a Church property. I won’t dare to speculate whether this is just a coincidence, or if it proves dominance of one specific institution in the Polish secular state ;-)

The trip was eventually in some 70% sponsored by a carefree driver who rear-ended me in Jelenia Góra. The speed at which the rear of my car was hit was low (again, inattention and centimetres lacking to make it a near-miss) and I was lucky not to sustain any neck injury (cervical spine is very sensitive to such accidents) and the damage done to my car was negligible. Upon checking the exhaust system and boot door lock remained intact, the culprit and I agreed on a few hundred PLN compensation for visibly scratched paintwork on the rear bumper. The damage doesn’t diminished the car’s utility value and it earned me some dough…

A propos motoring. After the period of run-up to Euro 2012 when several kilometres of roads were being modernised and built and ordeal drivers had to go through, now we can enjoy much higher standard of expressways and motorways – the wait was worthwhile! This was the first time I drove the newly built almost 100-kilometre long section of S8 (I last was there in September 2012, a month before opening) between Mszczonów and Piotrków Trybunaski and for the first time drove without even having to downshift to 4th gear 102 kilometres from Kostomłoty (junction on A4 motorway west of Wrocław) to Syców, where S8 expressway ends and turns into National Road no. 8, full of big trucks, small towns and numerous speed cameras… The missing section between Piotrków and Syców is under construction, due to be opened in 2015. Fills with hope. Actually driving the decent roads is faster and safer, but not necessarily cheaper. Unless you hold your horses and move excruciatingly slowly (100 kmph in my car is the speed above which fuel consumption begins to soar, from 6 litres of petrol per 100 km when the car does 100 kmph, to 8 litres when speed rises to 130 kmph and some 10 litres if I reach 150 kmph), the journey will set you back more (even more if you go via toll motorways, not the case this time) – but at the end of the day, comfort has its price…

Sunday, 12 May 2013

Poles aged 30 – portrayed, but accurately?


From time to time journalists of Gazeta.pl (online flank of Agora S.A., one of the most influential, leftist-liberal, media holdings in Poland) come up with series of articles dwelling on social problems. Quite recently two of them encouraged readers of the portal, aged near 30, to share with wider audience how their dwellings looked and what their material status in terms of housing conditions was. I usually keep track of such series with some does of curiosity, but that time I impatiently waited for each consecutive article, then read each of them with bated breath and avidly followed record-long comment threads…

The larger project run in attempt to paint a collective portrait of generation of 30-year-old Poles began by posing a question why people born in early 1980s are reluctant to have children. In the next step journalists resolved to find out where and how those people live and how the finance their housing needs.

The first article is a string of brief stories which paint a bitter-sweet picture…

Kaśka, aged 32, and her husband co-rent a room in a bigger flat. It’s cheaper and more practical, yet at times inconvenient. Their salaries would suffice to rent a tiny flat in a shanty town, but they prefer a 20-metre room in a flat shared with other people. Tensions sometimes appear, but when they are in need, they may count on their flatmates. In the meantime they put aside money to have equity and get mortgage on more favourable conditions. As for now, no bank finds them creditworthy. Purchase of property with cash – out of reach.

Błażej, aged 30, lives with his girlfriend in her 42 sqm flat (probably inherited or bought by her parents, photo suggests it’s located in Służew, part of Mokotów district, Warsaw). Given his girlfriend’s and his earnings, they wouldn’t be capable to service any mortgage debt, nor to rent any flat. Their aspirations have been fulfilled. Probably hadn’t it been for the windfall (his girlfriend’s own flat), they would live with parents…

Agata, aged 31, and her husband live in a mortgaged flat. Shortly after getting married they lived in a rented flat, then when a child’s birth was imminent, they took out a loan. Month by month, they move closer towards “full ownership” of their flat.

Piotrek, aged 30, and his wife, with some support of their parents and bank financing, bought a 70 sqm on city fringes. In his view this was a fair trade-off between location and size. Debt burden is not excessive and the flat would be spacious enough when children are born.

Anka, aged 29, is also one of those better-off. Since she was 20 she lived in flats inherited after family, currently she and her husband live in a house built on a plot donated to them by husband’s parents. She’d be damned if she dared to complain about her housing conditions.

The stories above bring a moderate dose of optimism. All character manage, some better, some worse, but are satisfied with what the have and keep cheerful. When you begin to read next sent in pieces, smile is immediately wiped off you face…

Sferyczna, single woman, aged 30. Lives in Warsaw, but hails from provincial Poland. Worked for a while abroad, but has not managed to save any money. Currently rents a tiny room in a tiny flat and estimates is 5 years will be eligible for a mortgage. Interestingly, she claims to earn more than peanuts and still she declares she can afford very little…

Karolina, aged 31, and Marcin, aged 36, have one child and live in an old flat that could do with a comprehensive refurbishment. Mortgage is a huge burden for them, each unplanned expenditure or a second child would blow over their budget. Loan instalments make up more than half of their income – this speaks for itself…

Next piece contains two contrary opinions. Rafał, aged 31, and his wife wonder whether only grumblers are around. He wants his voice to be audible. Instead of grumbling his wife and he toil away up to 60 hours per week, have built a house and bring up two daughters. Not a word about any mortgage, but he mentions his father who runs a prosperous company. Despite having little spare time, he claims he is happy and encourages to sheer hard work, which, as he believes is a key to the door of financial and personal success.

Marek, aged 27, has co-rented a flat since coming to Warsaw 5 years ago. With his earnings, little more than 2,000 PLN after tax, he can only afford to rent a small flat and pay maintenance charges, this all sets him back some 1,500 PLN – after this he has 600 PLN to spend on food, travels, clothes, entertainment??? He sees future in anything, but bright colours – with his earnings he stands no chance to get a mortgage and own any property…

Need something upbeat, don’t continue reading… A 30-year-old single woman has just bought her own flat. The mortgage and refurbishment loans have both 23-year repayment schedules, but her own flat is a step forward after years of renting and sinking money to landlord’s pocket. Living conditions are pretty dire, but glimmers of hope bring about smile on her face. In a few months the flat will be finished. As for now, she saves on everything, including food and scrapes along, to service debt timely…

Another confession, written by a 29-year-old man. He works in a public sector, is employed for a finite period and earns minimum wage. No chance to move out of parents’ house, even to rent anything. No prospects of becoming self-supporting, of raising family, no feeling of stability. He’s angry with those who stigmatise his peers who keep living with parents. In fact many of them do this not out of fear of taking responsibility for their lives, of facing adulthood, etc., but they stick to their parents for purely financial reasons. When earning 1,500 PLN after tax, attempt to taste independence is like being thrown at the deep end… Hopes for future… None… just prospects of barely getting by…

Not yet miserable? Carry on! A 31-year-old single woman has a single-bedroom mortgaged flat, but she and her daughter live with her parents. The graduate of Polish studies and Journalism, since finishing school changed jobs many times. Each was supposed to have been temporary, before she found something more desirable. In 2010, with support of her parents and a bank she bought a flat. Soon after she was offered a new job, left the previous, well-paid one, and eventually was left out in the cold, because the new employer changed its mind. Never jobless, she had next temporary, poorly-paid jobs which allowed her to pay bills and mortgage instalments. A year after it turned out she was pregnant with a man who turned out to be too irresponsible to fulfil role of a father. To make ends meet, she moved to her parents and lets her flat to repay the mortgage… She wipes every night and slowly is losing hope for a better tomorrow…

Let’s face it – those letters have been picked out of several sent in to Gazeta.pl’s editorial room. The picture of the generation which emerges is a matter of who and on the basis of what criteria chooses which letters to publish.

More interesting are plentiful comment threads under the articles, counting several hundred entries. Comments can be divided into a few categories…

Predictably, quite a few commentators trot out the “young, educated, from big cities” myth – they argue the depicted misery bears a truthful testimony how in fact the “Green Island” looks like and what the youngsters got from the party they had voted for. How long before people realise politicians’ influence on people’s everyday is much smaller than they claim? Misery of many young people can’t be put down to “feckless rule of losers and traitors”, while if the biggest oppositional party came to power, it wouldn’t turn Poland into a land of milk and honey. Society and economy are driven by actions of millions of individuals, not by decisions and deeds of few politicians. They don’t have power to heal the country and, on the other side, have little power to screw things up. If I were to be malicious, I could say between 2005 and 2007 property prices in Poland soared by almost 100%, hence becoming less affordable.

Some commentators point out those stories do not hold water – why somebody takes out a loan and than changes a job, for a worse-paid one, how some of mortgage instalments calculations match with what somebody has left at their discretion, etc.? Some even claim the stories sound so incredulously that they appear concocted.

The more ruthless advise authors of the letter who take pity on themselves to blame themselves, not the rest of the world. Who made them choose dead-end studies? Who precluded them from working harder? Who told them to change jobs several times?

Other group indicate young Poles have over-inflated expectations regarding consumption and earnings, while it takes time to grow into wealth. The only way to consume more than you can afford to is living beyond means, which means living with a ball and chain in form of debts and praying luck streak doesn’t cease, as then the frail wealth collapses.

For my part – I have no right to complain… I’m better of in comparison to some 99% of my peers. I don’t live in my own flat, but this is only my choice – I can afford to rent or take out a mortgage, but since there’s no pressure to move out I keep living in my parents’ house (and give them little money each month) and put aside some 70% of my salary. I earn very decently and have prospects of even higher earnings, but on the other hand at the back of my hand there’s a seed of uncertainty – my employer knows how to send adrenaline rising and having seen people being fired (with 1-day notice and generous severance packages) I realise no matter how committed I am, one I day I can have an inadvertent slip-up or my employer may change strategy and back out of business segment I work at, resulting in my job contract being terminated. I have job contract for indefinite period and well-above national average salary, but in return am offered no stability. I don’t go mad with the awareness each day might be the last day of my work only because I don’t have to provide for a family and have no debts to settle.

I’m also far from sharing opinions of those telling those unhappy people to blame only themselves. Success, not only financial, is a combination of many factors, including parentage (if your parents are wealthy, you’re better off at the start), skills (many are inborn I believe, you may develop them or not, but if you really lack a specific skill, developing it won’t get you far), hard work (inborn skills without hard work are useless) and luck… Every day I happen to realise where I am now and what I do is just a stroke of fate… Of course I can’t pronounce it’s prudent to take dead-end studies in political sciences, change jobs frequently, or get pregnant with an immature man, but in some cases people are inarguably out of luck and telling them to blame themselves proves only lack of empathy. Not everyone has a chance to be born in the capital city, in well-off family, to have educated parents. Most people have it up-hill and in Poland I can’t honestly say others have it downhill.

I recently calculated, with my above-average earnings and possibility to put aside most of my salary, if I was to start saving from scratch now, I’d have to save for 6 years to buy an average 50 sqm flat in Warsaw, assuming property prices stayed unchanged. Some time ago I read an average Pole would have to save for 11 years their whole salary to buy such flat. Imagine this – live with your parents for 11 years, let them feed you, don’t buy clothes, cosmetics, don’t go out, don’t travel and after 11 years you can buy a flat for cash. If your parents can’t support you financially you can only take out a huge burden on your back and pray nothing goes wrong along the way. How young Poles live is an aftermath of still steep, in comparison to earnings, property prices in Poland. As many market specialist claim, only increased supply of dwellings could help solve this problem – this can be achieved in form of public-private partnerships – local governments building in partnership with property developers council flats for rent. But for this you need a proper legal framework and wise and honest people to run such schemes. Out of reach, just like own flat for an average Pole turning 30…

Apologies in advance for taking a break from blogging next week. I’m holidaying… At last :-)